The economics of enterprise transformation: an analysis of the defense acquisition system

Show full item record

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/1853/28171

Title: The economics of enterprise transformation: an analysis of the defense acquisition system
Author: Pennock, Michael James
Abstract: Despite nearly 50 years of attempts at reform, the US defense acquisition system continues to deliver weapon systems over budget, behind schedule, and with performance shortfalls. Why has acquisition reform failed? Three potential contributors were identified in the literature: the misalignment of incentives, a lack of a systems view, and a lack of objective evaluation criteria. This thesis considers these problems in the context of the most recent effort to transform the defense acquisition enterprise, evolutionary acquisition. First, game theory was employed to analyze the incentives of participants in the defense acquisition enterprise regarding the use of immature technology. It was found that there is a tragedy of the commons at work where acquisition programs serve as a common resource for stakeholders to meet their goals. The result is that participants are incentivized to use immature technology in contradiction of evolutionary acquisition policies. Second, the cost and performance of evolutionary acquisition in the context of the defense acquisition system was analyzed using a discrete event simulation. What was found was that evolutionary acquisition may lead to better performance from fielded systems and lower cost programs but also that the cost of operating the acquisition system as whole may actually rise. Finally, a method using price indices was developed to translate the gain in buying power resulting from improvements to the defense acquisition system into a monetary valuation. This allows for the application of options analysis to determine whether or not it is cost effective to pursue a potential improvement. A comparison with a more traditional approach revealed that simply using the NPV of cost savings may significantly understate value.
Type: Dissertation
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/1853/28171
Date: 2008-03-06
Publisher: Georgia Institute of Technology
Subject: Stochastic processes
Discrete event simulation
Decision analysis
Options analysis
Game theory
Defense acquisition
United States. Dept. of Defense Procurement
Defense contracts
Department: Industrial and Systems Engineering
Advisor: Committee Chair: Rouse, William; Committee Member: Boff, Kenneth; Committee Member: Cross, Stephen; Committee Member: Griffin, Paul; Committee Member: Keskinocak, Pinar
Degree: Ph.D.

All materials in SMARTech are protected under U.S. Copyright Law and all rights are reserved, unless otherwise specifically indicated on or in the materials.

Files in this item

Files Size Format View
pennock_michael_j_200805_phd.pdf 727.5Kb PDF View/ Open

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show full item record